New-York News

Lease fight erupts over dormant Times Square Theater project


A rent dispute in Times Square threatens to derail a high-profile and long-dormant retail project as it attempts a pivot to residences.

Stillman Development International, which has been working to redevelop the historic Times Square Theater at 217 W. 42nd St. since 2017, has sued its landlord over a tripling of its rent.

The rent for the city-owned, Beaux-Arts edifice near Seventh Avenue jumped from $50,000 a month to $160,000 a month May 1, according to a source familiar with the matter.

Stillman, which apparently has been unable to revive a $150 million retail-conversion project planned before the pandemic, believes the new rent is way too steep for what’s still a development site, the source added. The firm sued in a legal maneuver to lock in the current rent — and to keep the city from taking back the colonnaded property — while the court hears the lease fight.

If city officials don’t address the developer’s complaint, they need to return Stillman’s $60 million stake in the project, plus interest and fees, the lawsuit says.

A spokesman for the city’s law office had no comment by press time. And a spokeswoman for The New 42nd Street, the city-selected nonprofit that functions as the theater’s landlord, also had no comment.

But Stillman’s lease changes were likely expected. According to the terms of the original 2017 lease, a 73-year deal at the time, The New 42nd Street could raise rents if the theater had no building permits in place after a certain amount of time, the source said.

At first, Stillman sought a retail use for the Times Square Theater, which opened in 1920, was converted into a movie theater in 1934 and closed for good in the late 1980s amid a seedy downturn for the neighborhood, according to the Cinema Treasures website. The $150 million plan, which called for adding several glass-walled floors atop the original limestone structure, at one point envisioned charging a single tenant $20 million a year for a seven-level space. But the proposal collapsed in early 2020 as Covid hit.

And the plan has reportedly not aged well, with tenants and lenders now skittish about such a large retail commitment, forcing Stillman to switch gears. The developer now seeks to put a rental tower above the unlandmarked theater with a mix of market-rate and affordable housing, the source explained, though the proposal has not gotten much past the design stage.

Stillman’s court filing is what is known as a “yellowstone injunction,” a move to stave off eviction in a landlord-tenant dispute until a judge rules on the case. Roy Stillman, Stillman’s president, declined to comment, and his lawyer could not be reached.


C. J. Hughes , 2024-05-22 19:30:10

Source link

Related posts

Steve Hartman goes "On the Road" to catch a glimpse of the eclipse


Archdiocese in contract to sell East Village's shuttered St. Emeric church


Beloved UES market expanding to Long Island City this winter


This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy